December 9, 2021
Planning Commission meeting

Public Comments

92 Comments
X DateX ZIP Code
Amanda
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Amanda (37920), November 1, 2021 at 11:03 AM
Please see attached letter
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211101110327.pdf
Angela
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Angela (37920), November 21, 2021 at 8:41 PM
I purchase my property during to it being a more rural, natural setting. I wanted a home that was more nature then urban, crowded and busy. I wanted to be able yo see the deer in the morning and evening, hear the birds sing during the day, be able yo open my windows and smell the fresh air. If I wanted to live where there were houses all around me, I would have purchased a home in or near the city. BUT I did not. Please do not allow Seviervill Pike to become just another housing development allow those of us that live here to enjoy South Knoxville for the reasons we moved here. Don't destroy our dreams for someone else's pocketbook.
Bethany
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Bethany (37920), November 1, 2021 at 8:18 PM
This piece of land needs to stay as it is. Traffic on Chapman highway is dangerous enough without adding more traffic. It is also important for our wildlife in the area to maintain this land as their habitat.
Blake
37920
11-B-21-SP
Blake (37920), November 23, 2021 at 8:30 AM
My wife and I relocated here four years ago. One of the reasons we moved was because we could literally see the developers' bulldozers from our kitchen window where we used to see farmland. We bought our house because of the natural woods all around, even though it's close to conveniences. We are beyond disappointed to hear plans to clear so much of the woods. Our property is directly adjacent to the subject property. Please do not allow this to destroy this community. Besides our personal concerns, the traffic, infrastructure and environmental issues are huge.
Bradley
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Bradley (37920), November 1, 2021 at 10:28 AM
Please see attached petition for 150 plus citizens against this rezoning request.

View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211101102809.pdf
Bradley
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Bradley (37920), November 1, 2021 at 10:36 AM
Please see the attached letter below against the rezoning of 8802 Old Sevierville Pike
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211101103640.pdf
Bradley
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Bradley (37920), December 1, 2021 at 2:49 PM
The process to amend the sector plan is not being followed. No improvements or changes have been made to accommodate or institute a plan amendment. The current sewer capacity was installed many years ago to accommodate the industrial area behind Valley Grove Church not for future housing developments according to knox Chapman. It was also already in place in 2012 when the sector plan was last reviewed. The turn lane recently added to Chapman Highway has been in the works by TDOT for many years and was intended to be a buffer zone for opposing traffic not to accommodate for a vast increase in traffic levels these developments will produce.
Bradley
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Bradley (37920), December 8, 2021 at 10:27 AM
Please see attached file of 560 singed against the rezoning and amending the growth plan
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211208102729.pdf
Bradley
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Bradley (37920), November 24, 2021 at 3:37 PM
Please see attached petition of 450 people against the rezoning and growth sector plan changes for case 11-f-21-rz
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211124153744.pdf
Brandy
37920
11-B-21-SP
Brandy (37920), November 24, 2021 at 7:41 PM
Please stop this rezone! Our wildlife, schools, roads, & community can NOT take something like this! It will crush our community. Please stop this!!
Brenda
37920
11-B-21-SP
Brenda (37920), November 22, 2021 at 7:36 PM
I would be very interested if there has been a study on how our roads are going to handle the additional traffic, We are jsut now finally beginning to see some improvement from the recent up grades, Now we are throwing all the hoses that are planned on Highland view , The houses 2-per acre on Old Sevierville pike. nxt they are planning townhouses directly on Chapman. Also would love to see what plans are being made for our Schools to handle the additional Children. New Hopewell is crowded with out buildings and been promise a new school for years , I feel so sad to lose yet another area that was home to deer, birds, even a bat cave that is just being bulldozed over. I know housing is needed and I am sure most area people would be receptive to less houses per acre leaving trees intact. But if you drive back you will see thousands of trees have pull cut already or bulldozed down. Lots of grade work is going on daily,
Briana
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Briana (37920), November 22, 2021 at 5:01 PM
I am writing to oppose this development. Sevierville Pike and other less-traveled roads in the area are already becoming overwhelmed by vehicle traffic. In 2019, traffic counts reported 1,084 vehicles on a section of Sevierville Pike near the intersection of Bays Mountain Road. The planned development would no doubt more than double this vehicle count. Additionally, construction will harm local waterways as well as disrupt wildlife corridors.
Brittany
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Brittany (37920), November 15, 2021 at 7:16 PM
Our schools, our underfunded fire departments, our whacked out highway (where you already take your life in your hands on each run) do NOT need this. Cookie cutter boxes with 3 inches of yard are what they do in California, not East Tennessee. People are COMING from those places to escape such living. I get that jobs are arriving in the area (yay) and real estate is premium. I get that this is America and we value our right to grow businesses, including real estate, within certain limits of the law. However, I don't want to go from being capitalists to having consumer-driven communities where no value is put on preservation, scene, or space. IN THE LEAST, please don't allow four houses per acre. It's an eyesore. Who is gonna wanna come here if we scrape away every inch of good country to start yet another subdivision? More like... an overdivision.
Brittany
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Brittany (37920), November 1, 2021 at 7:24 PM
I'm really excited about this development, I hope we can purchase a home!
Bruce and Lisa
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Bruce and Lisa (37920), December 6, 2021 at 11:02 AM
We adamantly oppose the re-zoning of the 1.21 acre parcel at 2816 Alcoa Hwy to Mixed Use Special District zoning (case 12-A-21-SP). This is a peaceful neighborhood with low crime and families that enjoy walks in their neighborhood. There are many commercial locations within close proximity that are sitting abandoned that would serve as much better commercial locations. To put a business on this small parcel, at the main entrance of the neighborhood brings no value to its residents or the community. This addition would only devalue all of our investments and bring more traffic and unwanted elements into the area.
Cassie
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Cassie (37920), December 6, 2021 at 10:31 AM
I do not support a business at the entrance of Martha Washington Heights neighborhood. We walk to the neighborhood every night and my son has walks to friends houses as well. The increased traffic would greatly impact the peacefulness and safety of the neighborhood and I do not believe it would add value.
Charlene
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Charlene (37920), December 7, 2021 at 2:54 PM
My husband and I do not support the rezoning of this property. As relatively new inhabitants of the wonderful neighborhood of Martha Washington Heights, we love the quiet and safety of our new home. A commercial property at the entrance to our neighborhood would be a blight that would decrease property values, increase traffic, and potentially increase crime. This is a family neighborhood with homeowners that are proud of their houses. We neither desire nor need this proposed commercial space.
Charles
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Charles (37920), December 7, 2021 at 7:36 PM
At approximately 1.25 acres, considering the practical use of a tract that size, and the terrain. The tract appears to have no practical use that would be beneficial to the residents of Martha Washington Heights. This tract is also in close proximity to other commercial properties that have been vacant for some time. This is just a bad idea.
Charles
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Charles (37920), December 8, 2021 at 12:26 PM
I oppose the rezoning request. There is plenty of abandoned shopping center space already present on Dresser Road. Please renovate and use it instead. This lot is at the front of neighborhood's main entrance. I think having green space there instead of a commercial establishment looks much better and adds to the more value of the neighborhood and its homes.
Charles
37920
12-A-21-SP
Charles (37920), December 8, 2021 at 12:26 PM
I oppose the rezoning request. There is plenty of abandoned shopping center space already present on Dresser Road. Please renovate and use it instead. This lot is at the front of neighborhood's main entrance. I think having green space there instead of a commercial establishment looks much better and adds to the more value of the neighborhood and its homes.
Charles
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Charles (37920), December 6, 2021 at 3:56 PM
I oppose Amendment 12-G-21-RZ as well as 12-A-21-SP. This seems to be a sudden move that has not until the last day or so even been accompanied by a notice sign at the subject parcel location. These amendments would negatively affect our neighborhood; approval would be contrary to the will of the people impacted. If the owner wishes to see development that suits the character and harmony of the neighborhood, why doesn't he reserve such small parcels in his vast inventory for green space? His parcels in commercial and industrial areas would still generate revenue and profits. Alternately, the owner could explore using his property as it is currently zoned. Given the shortage and high values of residential property these days, this wooded area could nest one or more upper bracket residences. This would improve neighborhood home values, instead of jeopardizing them as would an expanded nearby shopping center, with its consequences of added noise, congestion, loitering, light pollution, etc. In contrast to the shortage of quality green space and residential properties in our immediate area, there is already an abundance of unused commercial space spread throughout this area, on both sides of Alcoa Highway fronting this parcel. Thank you for your careful consideration in representing the people on this issue.

View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211206155658.pdf
Chris
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Chris (37920), December 8, 2021 at 2:48 PM
I want to echo the well written words of my many neighbors in MWH and cordially request this development be vetoed.

I have lived here 10 years and the green nature of the neighborhood is what makes it so great! I also agree with others on points regarding the unoccupied businesses very close by. Why rezone that space when there has been unoccupied businesses close by the whole decade I have beenhere.
Chris
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Chris (37920), December 8, 2021 at 12:47 PM
As a resident of Martha Washington Heights, I speak in opposition of the proposed rezoning of the property at the entrance to our neighborhood.
Cynthia
37920
11-B-21-SP
Cynthia (37920), November 21, 2021 at 8:16 AM
My family and I have lived in this community since 1970. It is a wonderful, rural community and the woods and fields that make up the proposed development that is behind us has been the same since that time. It has been used for running cattle, horse shows, etc, and because of the huge cave and caverns located on the property, we thought it would always remain the same. Many of the children in the area played and explored all in the area. Please do not let Thunder Mountain ruin our community by bringing in a 450 house develop that will swallow up all of our wildlife and beauty. The view as you turn off Chapman Highway at Highland Cemetery has remained the same since I was a child and has always been a comfort when arriving home. Please consider all of the current residents and their homes they currently enjoy, as well as the small businesses & vote no on this rezoning.
11-B-21-SP
Dan (37920), November 3, 2021 at 11:49 PM
The community is opposed to this rezoning. 

This is a rural area. 4 DU per acre is too dense.

Nature. There are concerns about the water shed, potential flooding and impacts to wild life.

Traffic. There is not a traffic light at Chapman Hwy. It would be irresponsible to allow this level of density without additional traffic control infrastructure.

Beauty. Spec house developments are abominations to the landscape. Knoxville can do better than generic suburban sprawl that enriches short term speculators at the expense of community.
Darryl & Cindy
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Darryl & Cindy (37920), December 6, 2021 at 8:53 AM
I respectfully request that the rezoning request be denied for this case. This would create adverse effects to the residents of this subdivision, as the request covers the entry way and another side road which is the primary access to the subdivision, and would be extremely detrimental to the neighborhood and adjacent neighbors, due to increased traffic, blockage of the entry and property value to owners who have lived in this subdivision 40 years plus. Thank you for your consideration to NO REZONE.
Dawn
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Dawn (37920), December 1, 2021 at 5:21 PM
Please see my letter OPPOSING rezoning and sector plan change for this property (Case # 11-F-21-RZ and Case # 11-F-21-SP), attached.
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211201172101.pdf
Dawn
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Dawn (37920), December 1, 2021 at 5:23 PM
Photos of devastation on subject property. Two TDEC cases pending...
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211201172321.pdf
Dawn
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Dawn (37920), December 1, 2021 at 5:52 PM
I live across the street from the subject property in the historic "Loveday Springs" Greek Revival home, built by Ben Bowers (owner of Camel Manufacturing, itself of historical local significance) in the 1930's. Run by the Loveday family, the site was also the main stagecoach stop between Knoxville and Sevierville from 1837-1903. The tavern ruins, stone spring box, stone bridge and cast metal bell used to summon the livery staff from that bygone era still exist today. Adding 4 du/acre across the street from this unique historical treasure is NOT in character with the neighborhood. Please VOTE NO on re-zoning and VOTE NO on sector plan change for this property. Do not let one out-of-town developer destroy all that is good and glorious and God-given in our neighborhood and replace it with dangerous traffic, silted streams, cheek-to-jowl housing, over-crowding, flooding and more--merely to grant a one-time windfall to the three out-of-town people (TMP, the developer) at the expense of myself and all our neighbors. Please retain the Agricultural zoning and the Rural Area designation of this land to limit the developer to a more appropriate project in character with the surrounding neighborhood. NO Harden Valley in our neighborhood!!! 
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211201175241.pdf
Dawn
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Dawn (37920), December 1, 2021 at 6:06 PM
There is a large bat cave located on the land at 8802 Sevierville Pike. The horizontal opening of the cave has been disturbed by recent activity with heavy equipment (the mouth of the cave is partially filled with soil). The land also lies within what is termed "Critical Bat Habitat" on the following map: Critical Habitat for Threatened & Endangered Species [USFWS] (arcgis.com). There MUST be an environmental impact study done on this property prior to ANY changes that would allow development greater than the current zoning and sector plan change allow. It MUST be determined what impact there might be on bats that are endangered by White Nose Syndrome!!!

View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211201180631.pdf
Denise
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Denise (37920), December 4, 2021 at 8:41 PM
As a resident of Martha Washington Heights for almost 50years I am mortified to read about the proposed use of the 1.21acres near the entrance to the subdivision.It is a lovely neighborhood.The property values would plummet and traffic would increase exponentially.I am very disturbed by the ease with which others try to slide things past the residents.
Diane
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Diane (37920), December 3, 2021 at 9:41 AM
I am directly influenced by the re zoning and building of said shopping center and wish you would vote against. We have one small acre of trees and shrub, bird and animal habitat between us and the Alcoa Hwy speedway. What do you want this sweet Scruffy City to become? Little by little it happens, another Nashville. ( We lived there and have seen the massive development and how loss of tree and green space have increased the heat.) There are so many spots along that road that seem ready for development.
 
Please let us keep our tiny green space. Is Knoxville just about business now? Let us take a stand and use space ready for business that exists along that road. We are all ready losing acres of mature hardwoods for a massive apt. project off Malony Road.
Diane
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Diane (37920), December 8, 2021 at 2:18 PM
This is my second comment, due to I feel like I have so much to say.First, why did Mr Monday do this now? At the Holidays? Thinking we would just roll over and not notice amidst the holidays? Everyone, every family and child busy?
 
We are just waking up, we as Martha Washington Heights are just trying to get the news out! We are just wanting to save our little green acre! Please come to this space, see the desolate abandoned businesses up and down both sides of the new interstate Alcoa Hwy. Give us our one remaining little peace PEACE of greenery. Seems like this whole process is so sided to favor the developer while the little guy has to really stand up and fight to be heard. While all along, living and raising families and trying to stay healthy ect. a Mr Monday can just decide to change our world over here so easily. It is not right. Once again I beg of you to vote against this re zone. Seems like it should be required by said developer to meet with adjoining neighborhood to discuss plans? Again , the system is geared to favor developer. He will not even tell us his plans. My plan, our neighborhood plans are to keep our little green acre.
 
Vote NO.
Dinah
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Dinah (37920), December 7, 2021 at 7:40 AM
Please do not pass this rezoning request. it would be a hardship for the entire older neighborhood of Martha Washington Heights. Our entryway was just finished and we don't want to add added traffic with a shopping center at the edge of our entrance. There is already a shopping center very close to where this would be if built. It would devalue the property of the homeowners that would be next to a shopping center. Thank you.
Donald
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Donald (37920), November 16, 2021 at 8:12 PM
The plan for the land you thinking of rezoning. Is far ahead of it's time. By at least 20 years..This area is not ready or do we want to be the next Florida or NC. With insufficient Police, Fire department and schools. The Community should of had much more notice than a few signs . A developer who has already done more unreversible damage to The land and me personally. They riped a 1/3 of my fence down along with a redbud tree Transplanted from my deceased mother's farm witch was on our land. Not letting us know allowing are 4 dogs to rome at will. This is just The start of the madness . The trespassing will Only get worse. Put a stop too this before it is to much for our roads ,schools Sheriff.and fire Department can handle. Concerned citizen.
Gerald
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Gerald (37920), December 7, 2021 at 9:34 AM
Please do not rezone this property. It was originally zoned residential and should stay that way. We've endured 4-years of Alcoa Hwy. construction and now he wants to put much more traffic on the entrance to our homes? Failed business buildings lining the road to this property include the former Hardee's, National Fitness, Window Tinting plus most of the strip center that contains the church. Odds are not good for new business to succeed there.
Jack
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Jack (37920), December 7, 2021 at 2:52 PM
My wife and I oppose this rezoning.This tract is the last buffer between the Martha Washington Heights neighborhood entrance and commercial development on Alcoa Highway. Many people walk to and through the neighborhood and we do not want more automobile traffic through our neighborhood from a shopping destination just outside the entrance.
Jamie
37920
11-B-21-SP
Jamie (37920), December 1, 2021 at 9:44 AM
My community of Dry Hollow has banded together to fight this proposal. I, myself, am urging you to please deny this rezone. The protected hillsides that have already been destroyed are a travesty. This type of growth was never intended for this area. This was meant to stay rural in the Planning Commission’s own proposed 20 year plan. The traffic at the intersection of Chapman Hwy and Simpson Rd. is already dangerous even with the new middle lane added. We moved here to have a feel of being away from the city and with this development it completely ruins that. This must not happen! Please consider all of us that have come together to fight this.
Jane
37920
12-A-21-SP
Jane (37920), December 7, 2021 at 8:47 AM
This residential property is now the new face for our Martha Washington Heights subdivision . This entrance is a reflection of our community and of our investments in this community. The incursion of a business structure, signs, parking lot, dumpsters, light and ground pollution at the entrance of our subdivision is a direct threat to those investments. The plague of empty businesses along this corridor of Dresser Rd. also has a negative effect on those investments. Please to do not add another until the Alcoa Highway Project proves this corridor is viable for businesses. I oppose the re-zoning of residential property case # 12-A-21–SP and ask the commissioners to visit our community before the final vote. I hope your decisions will support and validate this community and our investments in it….
Janice
37920
12-A-21-SP
Janice (37920), December 7, 2021 at 10:15 PM
I am a homeowner in the Martha Washington Heights subdivision. As a property owner, I am voicing concern over the proposed rezoning case of 12-A-21-SP. I would like to request the delay of voting on the proposal for at least 180 days to give the community an opportunity to understand the impact of this development on our neighborhood in regard to safety, traffic flow, noise levels and other environmental considerations. This directly impacts our neighborhood as well as property values. To date, there has not be an opportunity to have a community meeting with the owner of the property to better understand this proposal. As an engaged community citizen, I respectfully ask that you postpone voting on this proposal in order to allow for the appropriate vetting of this important decision.
Jayne
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Jayne (37920), December 7, 2021 at 4:04 PM
This small piece of property is the last remaining buffer between our neighborhood and the highway. We have watched trees come down and wildlife habitats that had been there for years disrupted and destroyed. The neighborhood was officially a bird sanctuary as well- please reconsider this. It is a small but it’s all we have left!
Jeff
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Jeff (37920), December 2, 2021 at 5:08 PM
I would request this zoning change be denied. The presence of a shopping center at this location would be extremely detrimental to the residents of Martha Washington Heights. There’s plenty of unoccupied retail space along Alcoa Highway. Please allow us to keep the last bit of green space that shields us from the ever expanding expressway.
Jennifer
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Jennifer (37920), December 2, 2021 at 6:19 PM
I live very close to the proposed rezoning site. My family and I chose to move here four years ago to have a home and community built of peace and quiet. We have a small vegetable farm and raise chickens. We love seeing the deer, fox, and the occasional coyote. The proposed development would increase traffic and public demand which will destroy the environment we love and try to protect. I know our sentiment is shared with the majority of neighbors who want to keep our tranquil community small.
jewel
37920
12-G-21-RZ
jewel (37920), December 1, 2021 at 3:21 PM
I object to the proposed commercial zoning referenced as case #12-g-21-rz. a very large portion on both sides of alcoa highway have numerous commercial vacant properties available for occupancy and use. this proposal encroaches upon the private and existing, established neighborhood of martha washington heights.
Jo Dell
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Jo Dell (37920), December 8, 2021 at 10:59 AM
I hope you will deny the rezoning request and sector plan change that is being requested by Mr. Monday. I have lived in Martha Washington Heights for 38 years. Our neighborhood is very family-friendly and the homes here, while older, are very well-maintained. We have a good sense of community in this area. The Alcoa Highway work seems as though it has gone on forever and the entrance to our subdivision was closed for months. We are glad this section is finally complete; however, now it seems that our neighborhood is under siege again from development pressures, using the road work as an excuse to change zoning. The 2012 sector plan deliberately excluded this parcel at the entrance to our neighborhood from the Mixed Use District and since it is only 1.21 acres, seems very inappropriate for Shopping Center zoning. It is my understanding that some of my neighbors have approached Mr. Monday about selling the parcel to the neighborhood so we can retain the residential zoning, but he has refused. Alcoa Highway has a surplus of depressed property zoned for Shopping Center use, so we don't need to add any more to this. This parcel is zoned residential and does not front Alcoa Highway. Instead, it fronts Dresser Road as it approaches Mt. Vernon Drive and could just as easily be developed as residential. Please honor the work put into the 2012 Sector Plan by planning staff as well as our community, and deny this rezoning.
Joanne
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Joanne (37920), December 6, 2021 at 10:17 AM
I am very opposed to a business or businesses occupying the proposed sight. This is a very nice, quiet neighborhood and I feel the added traffic and people would be a detriment to the quiet snd safe feeling of our neighborhood. We are not willing to sacrifice our quiet neighborhood for businesses to invade our privacy! There is already a shopping center in very close to this proposed sight. How about reviving this center.
John
37920
12-G-21-RZ
John (37920), December 6, 2021 at 8:48 PM
I oppose the rezoning of the small parcel of land at the entrance to Martha Washington Heights subdivision, of which I am a resident. The eventual presence of a business on this property would increase traffic in our neighborhood, devalue the residential properties next to the parcel in question, and likely eventually add yet another empty business location to the area. As an option, a nice green space would make a very pleasant entrance to the subdivision.
john
37920
12-G-21-RZ
john (37920), December 7, 2021 at 4:03 PM
This piece of property is the last remaining buffer between our neighborhood and the highway. We have watched trees come down and wildlife habitats that had been there for years disrupted and destroyed. The neighborhood was officially a bird sanctuary as well- please reconsider this. It is a small but it’s all we have left!
John
37920
12-G-21-RZ
John (37920), December 8, 2021 at 12:18 PM
-Seems like the Commission would want to wait until the Small Area Study of this Alcoa Hwy Corridor was completed (early 2022) before granting this additional damaging change to the neighborhood. Would have better data to work with.-Many neighbors are in favor of adding residential mass to the corridor area, so the existing blighted commercial areas can be rehabilitated. This change would go in the opposite direction.
karen
37920
11-F-21-RZ
karen (37920), November 2, 2021 at 1:23 PM
i understand the new owners are looking for quick money. there are sustainable future options for this property. i checked the existing creek system, which would be adversely affected by housing development. utilizing the creek system to a trout farm would give them a huge market as fish is in high demand as more byers are looking for local sources . developers ,city/county planners need to consider 100+ years down the road.
Kathy
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Kathy (37920), November 30, 2021 at 9:06 PM
I am a 14 year resident of Martha Washington Heights. I purchased my home here because of the county and residential zoning and the lack of commercial development and traffic that it brings. Me and my family are vehemently opposed to rezoning of this lot to SC or any other commercial zone. This is a residential family neighborhood and we want to keep it that way. The opinion of one property owner in this community shouldn't overrule the many voices that want it to remain residential.
Kelly
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Kelly (37920), December 6, 2021 at 8:13 PM
I oppose 12-G-21-RZ and 12-A-21-SP. MWH is a quiet subdivision and that is why people choose to live there. The area has more than enough empty commercial space that should be used first. Why destroy more trees and animal habitat. This area has already been disturbed enough by the construction on Alcoa Highway. This space would add more congestion and pollution to a peaceful neighborhood. I do not see any added value to to adding additional commercial space this area. This area needs more green space and less pavement. What are the environmental impacts to the neighborhood?
Laurie
37920
11-B-21-SP
Laurie (37920), December 8, 2021 at 12:59 PM
I would like to compliment the Commission on the Growth Policy Plan and the South Sector Plan that you developed over the years. It essentially establishes an urban growth limits line and protects the rural residential/ agricultural character of our Dry Hollow/Sevierville Pike area. It provides a vision that the residents count on.

This is the time to hold firm and back up your well crafted vision.

Amending the Plan with such a vast change in density will award the developer a financial windfall at the expense of our neighborhood and the community planning process that we rely on.

I urge you to vote No on the Sector Plan Amendment and No on the Rezone.
Linda
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Linda (37920), December 1, 2021 at 10:44 AM
I oppose the request to rezone 0 Mount Vernon Road, Cases# 12-A-21-SP and 12-G-21-RZ. Commuters and neighbors along Alcoa Highway need stores, restaurants, and other services enjoyed by residents in other parts of the county. However, there are plenty of vacant and rundown properties along the nearly completed Woodson to Maloney section that fill those needs and are awaiting redevelopment. A shopping center at the location proposed for rezoning, regardless of the prospective business, is unnecessary and ill timed. Further, the property stands at the entrance of Martha Washington Heights neighborhood which has about 150 houses with mature trees and well maintained houses. Prior to road construction a neighborhood entrance sign and landscaping with flowers and shrubs enhanced the neighborhood's attractiveness. A shopping center would do the opposite and detract from the value of our homes, increase traffic, and significantly impact the neighbors on Custis with light pollution and noise. As a resident of Martha Washington Heights neighborhood -- even with the scruffy looking entrance we are left with now but hope to improve -- I urge you to deny the request for rezoning. Thank you.

PS - Perhaps not applicable to the cases at this point but there is no sign posted at the property notifying people about the public hearing on December 9.
Lois
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Lois (37920), December 4, 2021 at 8:43 AM
This small piece of property is the last remaining buffer between our neighborhood and the highway. We have watched trees come down and wildlife habitats that had been there for years disrupted and destroyed. The neighborhood was officially a bird sanctuary as well- please reconsider this. It is a small but it’s all we have left!
Lora
37920
11-B-21-SP
Lora (37920), November 22, 2021 at 8:19 PM
Please do not rezone this area as residential. The resulting traffic flow and disruption to area wildlife would be disastrous. Please help us preserve this land in its natural state.
M. Nicole
37920
12-G-21-RZ
M. Nicole (37920), December 4, 2021 at 1:44 PM
My family and I strongly oppose the re-zoning of the 1.21 acre parcel at 2816 Alcoa Hwy to Mixed Use Special District zoning (case 12-A-21-SP). We purchased our home in the Martha Washington Heights neighborhood because of the low traffic, low crime, the well-kept houses and the walkable streets. The number of residents who exercise and walk their dogs through the neighborhood is amazing and wonderful. Having a pedestrian-friendly neighborhood benefits the health of the residents, benefits the community and the participating residents serve as a form of neighborhood watch. A shopping center at the beginning of our neighborhood would be harmful to the residents of MWH. The vehicular traffic would increase dramatically, as might crime. This would result in decreased property values and affect the safety of neighborhood residents. According to the Knox County property tax records the owner of the 1.21 acre parcel also owns the adjacent parcel where the vacant shopping center sits and he owns a plethora of commercial properties throughout Knoxville. He is not a resident of MWH and it's clear that preserving the integrity of the neighborhood is not uppermost in his mind.
Margie
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Margie (37920), November 1, 2021 at 3:28 PM
Wholesale, indiscriminate clearing of hundreds trees and illegal grading on site have already severely impacted site drainage, caused excessive erosion and displaced a large amount of wildlife. Once beautiful and productive farmland is now a tangle of debris, uprooted trees and raw, eroding soil—a complete eyesore caused by an utter disregard of good land management practices. The proposed rezoning to allow for 227 houses on quarter-acre lots will destroy the rural character of this neighborhood. Associated traffic on our narrow, curving rural roads would result in even more hazardous driving conditions than currently exist. Furthermore, the current request to rezone 63+ acres is only the first of several upcoming requests to rezone a total of nearly 400 acres on contiguous parcels owned by Thunder Mountain—the petitioners for rezoning—who have stated their intention to develop all of their holdings in the near future. Per Knox County's own Growth Policy Plan, the land is OUTSIDE of the Planned Growth Area; it is designated Rural Area in the Growth Policy Plan. I am completely opposed to the rezoning of this site and I respectfully request the proposed rezoning be denied.
Margie
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Margie (37920), November 29, 2021 at 2:03 PM
Please see my comments. Attachments to follow in separate comment.
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211129140350.pdf
Margie
37920
11-B-21-SP
Margie (37920), November 29, 2021 at 2:06 PM
Attachment for previous comment dated 11/29/21 - Hydrology Report
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211129140631.pdf
Margie
37920
11-B-21-SP
Margie (37920), November 29, 2021 at 2:08 PM
Attachment for previous comment on 11/29/21 (2 of 4)
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211129140823.pdf
Margie
37920
11-B-21-SP
Margie (37920), November 29, 2021 at 2:09 PM
Attachment for previous comment on 11/29/21 (3 of 4)
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211129140951.pdf
Margie
37920
11-B-21-SP
Margie (37920), November 29, 2021 at 2:11 PM
Final attachment for previous comment on 11/29/21
View Attachment
https://agenda.knoxplanning.org/attachments/20211129141105.pdf
Mary
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Mary (37920), December 7, 2021 at 9:09 AM
Please deny the request to approve the rezoning of the property on Dresser Road at the entrance to Martha Washington Heights subdivision. The area along Alcoa Highway has many commercial properties with empty buildings ready for commercial use. Three in particular were once shopping center/gas stations. Why clean out an area that is a buffer for the neighborhood for another commercial property when so many along that area of Alcoa Highway sit empty and ready for use?

The other concern is increased activity, noise and light pollution to an area that is currently a quiet, safe area. We already have two bars nearby that bring crime, murders to the area.
Matt
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Matt (37920), November 2, 2021 at 11:05 AM
I am totally against this planned rezoning and development. The roads are incapable of handling this increased amount of traffic. There are also issues with available capacity of current sanitary sewer. The wildlife in the area are being treated like the early Native Americans. It is a shame that those we elect to be our voice completely ignore the majority of the people. Would you want this development on Government Farm Road?
Matt
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Matt (37920), December 6, 2021 at 9:08 PM
This rezoning of a residential area as a shopping center should not be permitted. It's a beautiful area and nice, quiet neighborhood and the change in zoning and the shopping center would adversely affect all of that. There are plenty of other nearby commercial areas that could use an upgrade and there is no need to take away more green space and infringe on a neighborhood. I can't understand why this would be allowed to move forward without greater notice and opportunity for comments on it.
Micaela
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Micaela (37920), December 8, 2021 at 10:21 AM
I live in Marthe Washington Height, and I am opposed to the rezoning of the lots adjacent to our neighborhood as shopping center. Not only is there a shopping center already there with virtually all stores empty, there land adjacent is very steep and fully wooded. The grading of the land to make it suitable for building would subject the area to serious erosion, probably rapidly. The lack of woods would increase the traffic noise throughout the entire neighborhood, and possibly create traffic problems on our roads, which are not wide enough already.
Michael
37920
11-B-21-SP
Michael (37920), November 23, 2021 at 12:25 PM
This proposed plan is, and will continue, to destroy the rural feel of the rural setting that people moved here for. They've already demolished so many of the wildlife corridors that makes this area beautiful and they plan to demolish much more. The traffic problems alone that this development will cause is a concern for not only the Dry Hollow Community, but for the Seymour and South Knoxville community as a whole. These hillsides are supposed to be protected, but I don't see this developer abiding by any of hillside protection ordinances. Also according to the South Knoxville Growth Plan, this area was meant to stay rural. This type of growth should remain closer to the city.
Misty
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Misty (37920), November 23, 2021 at 6:26 PM
PLEASE DON'T REZONE! I was born and raised in South Knoxville and this commercialization is destroying the best parts. Part of what makes this area so great is that it's rural. The Hobbit Village has taken away from this community. Please don't take anymore. This will destroy our community.
12-G-21-RZ
Nan (37920), December 8, 2021 at 11:59 AM
I am writing in opposition to the vote to rezone this parcel from Residential to Shopping Center. This property now exists in its current "state" only because of the filling of the ravine to allow for the Alcoa Hwy Bridge/access road project(s). This property adjoins the back yards of some of our residents. There is currently commercial property vacant and available on both sides of Alcoa Hwy that could be repurposed that is already available for commercial use without destroying what little green space that remains. The Dresser Road/access road contains remnants of Court South, Hardees, Pilot Convenience store and other unsightly areas that are abandoned and unmaintained. I do not think a new shopping center zone would help with the appearance to the entrance of our neighborhood and would likely just create more unsightly space and dangerous traffic congestion. Traffic, blind turns, and related noise and congestion would detract from our neighborhood which has historically been quiet and nature oriented having been an unofficial bird sanctuary for years. I would like to request your vote against rezoning this property. Thank you.
Nicole
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Nicole (37920), October 6, 2021 at 9:01 AM
Opposed on multiple fronts, first being the road structure will not handle an extra 250-500 cars a day, with multiple accidents as is now. Second the charm and character of the rual farm land should be preserved and this land was originally zoned this way to preserve. The prior owners leveraged this for decreased tax liability to only sale with intent of development.
Norman
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Norman (37920), November 2, 2021 at 9:46 PM
Worried about safety for my family. Traffic on Sevierville Pk and Chapman Hwy and surrounding roads can’t handle it. Schools are over crowded now! Wildlife will have nowhere to roam. It will bring the prices of surrounding houses way down.
Private
37920
11-B-21-SP
Private (37920), November 26, 2021 at 6:20 PM
I am for this development ..due to the fact that we are living during a time where we have an on going HOUSING CRISIS. I think most of you know the story behind 'that' situation? I also have a small track of land that I would also like to have rezoned and add additional accessory buildings to rent at an AFFORDABLE rate giving the inflated price of homes and rental units. Most of the folks who are against this development are probably living under housing conditions of inheritable influence and are not under pressure to find an affordable place to rent, I'm assuming? As for the wild life, the deer travel through my land dusk and dawn and if they are not being hunted..are mostly safe as I do not hunt. More housing would also restrict these "sport hunters" from legally hunting in this general area unless they submit to poaching. I vote FOR this development
Rhonda
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Rhonda (37920), December 8, 2021 at 1:04 PM
I am in direct opposition for the property at the entrance of Martha Washington Heights Alcoa Highway entrance to be rezoned from residential to Shopping Center. As it is we have lost a good portion of our entrance to the overall Alcoa Highway Road Project. I would highly recommend the alternative action of revitalizing the existing buildings beginning with the Southgate Shopping Center and proceeding to the abandoned Pilot on the east side of the highway as a more efficient and cost effective measure. Additionally, the community has already lost the designated bird sanctuary at the front of the subdivision and a multitude of other wild animals to the highway project. The continued environmental impact would ultimately be devastating to the animals that make our community their home. I would also recommend the revitalization of the businesses/buildings existing on the west side of Alcoa Highway as well.
Robert
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Robert (37920), October 31, 2021 at 10:05 AM
I do not think that all this additional housing is positive move for Knoxville..It poses health and safety issues that out way any personal advances..
Robert
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Robert (37920), November 28, 2021 at 10:23 AM
The main reason I moved here is because it was rural. Do not rezone it.
Ronnie
37920
11-B-21-SP
Ronnie (37920), November 24, 2021 at 7:47 PM
STOP THE REZONE. This is our main concern. Keep our community rural!. Please dont let them take this from us. We been here our whole life and we know our community can not take it. Imagine how many fatal wrecks will be at the Chapman highway entrance/exit! Imagine the traffic jams. Imagine all the wildlife being gone. These are all things we don't want to happen. STOP THE REZONE
Scott
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Scott (37920), December 8, 2021 at 1:08 PM
I am in direct opposition for the property at the entrance of Martha Washington Heights Alcoa Highway entrance to be rezoned from residential to Shopping Center. As it is we have lost a good portion of our entrance to the overall Alcoa Highway Road Project. I would highly recommend the alternative action of revitalizing the existing buildings beginning with the Southgate Shopping Center and proceeding to the abandoned Pilot on the east side of the highway as a more efficient and cost-effective measure. Additionally, the community has already lost the designated bird sanctuary at the front of the subdivision and a multitude of other wild animals to the highway project. The continued environmental impact would ultimately be devastating to the animals that make our community their home. I would also recommend the revitalization of the businesses/buildings existing on the west side of Alcoa Highway as well.
Sharon
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Sharon (37920), December 6, 2021 at 9:11 PM
I object to the proposed commercial zoning case #12G 21 RZ. As others have stated our is a community of families who enjoy the peace and quiet of our well established neighborhood. This property is our only buffer against the noise from Alcoa Hwy. Besides lowering our property value due to dumpsters and trucks unloading in our backyard this will completely degrade what we have worked to build in our neighborhood where we have enjoyed peace , quiet and nature.
Stephanie
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Stephanie (37920), December 6, 2021 at 9:10 AM
I am a resident of Martha Washington Heights. Please DO NOT grant the rezoning request to Mr. Monday. Our neighborhood is nice and quiet and still somewhat secluded. I am worried about the traffic, pollution (noise, light, air) and possible unsavory activity, as shopping centers are often the scenes of criminal pursuits. We are finally getting some semblance of peace and order back into our neighborhood after the long period of highway construction. Now, Mr. Monday, in his greed, wants to ruin all of that. I and many residents of MWH are sick of greedy developers running roughshod over current residents. Again, please do NOT grant this rezoning request. Thank you.
Stephanie
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Stephanie (37920), December 7, 2021 at 9:05 AM
I realize that I have already submitted a comment, but I would like to add to it. This tiny piece of property is a buffer between MWH and Alcoa Highway. It protects the neighborhood from traffic noise and light. There are other properties along this stretch of road that are surely more suitable for whatever Mr. Monday has in mind. Please, please, DO NOT allow this parcel to be rezoned. Our property values and neighborhood aesthetic are at risk.
Stephanie
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Stephanie (37920), December 4, 2021 at 10:31 AM
I am opposed to the rezoning of this property. With such an abundance of vacant commercial properties in the vicinity it seems thoughtless to consider removing more green space before working on bringing the dilapidated commercial properties back to life. I am not opposed to development of the area in general, but it needs to be done in a way that adds to the beauty and vibrancy of our community, keeping wildlife and current residents in mind. Having lived in many cities across the U.S. I have witnessed plenty of development done both impeccably and poorly, and I want more for our community and our wonderful city than thoughtless, quick money making, junk development. What will this add to the currently dilapidated strip? Take care of that first.
Stephen
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Stephen (37920), December 7, 2021 at 6:18 PM
We have been residents of Martha Washington Heights for over 40 years. We strongly oppose this rezoning request. We are concerned that our neighborhood would no longer feel safe.Please save our neighborhood! Susan and Stephen
Susan
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Susan (37920), December 6, 2021 at 5:10 PM
I have been a resident of Martha Washington Heights for over 30 years. During this time there has been talk about making a safer entrance into our neighborhood. After many years, construction on Alcoa Highway began. Now after several years of construction, Martha Washington Heights has a safe entrance into the neighborhood. Rezoning this property to commercial use will once again cause unsafe conditions for residents of this neighborhood coming and going.

Besides the huge safety issue, having any commercial business this close to the new ramp into the neighborhood takes away the visibility for visitors, commercial delivery and repair services coming into the neighborhood.

I request that you deny the rezoning of this property.
Susan
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Susan (37920), December 8, 2021 at 12:44 PM
I am in opposition to the rezoning of the property at the entrance of Martha Washington Heights. I am a resident of MWH.
Susan
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Susan (37920), December 8, 2021 at 12:44 PM
I am in opposition to the rezoning of the property at the entrance of Martha Washington Heights. I am a resident of MWH.
Teddy
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Teddy (37920), December 7, 2021 at 11:46 AM
I would like to reiterate the below comment that has already been posted. Deny Deny Deny this rezoning. This will absolutely ruin this neighborhood.

Please deny the request to approve the rezoning of the property on Dresser Road at the entrance to Martha Washington Heights subdivision. The area along Alcoa Highway has many commercial properties with empty buildings ready for commercial use. Three in particular were once shopping center/gas stations. Why clean out an area that is a buffer for the neighborhood for another commercial property when so many along that area of Alcoa Highway sit empty and ready for use? The other concern is increased activity, noise and light pollution to an area that is currently a quiet, safe area. We already have two bars nearby that bring crime, murders to the area.
Ursula
37920
11-F-21-RZ
Ursula (37920), November 16, 2021 at 7:00 PM
An incredible overwhelming majority of the people in this community are opposed to rezoning this land.  I moved here specifically for the rural setting, community, and wildlife. This wilderness is the EXACT reason that South Knox is desirable. This is something we actually advertise! It doesn't work if you become concrete suburbia, devoid of forests and wildlife. If this is approved, we can never go back. Rezoning would destroy everything South Knox stands for and just create another Hardin Valley nightmare. Please take note that people are already very willing to build homes here, following the existing agriculture zoning requirements, without disrupting the beauty and uniqueness that makes this place special. I know because I'm one of them, and I know many others actively trying to do the same. This area is also not included in the growth plan. As others have already mentioned, changing the zoning without the needed, extensive roadway infrastructure would be reckless and only lead to more deaths on Chapman highway.
Walter
37920
12-G-21-RZ
Walter (37920), December 5, 2021 at 7:12 PM
The entrance to a residential subdivision defines its community. It is shared by all. Previously this entrance was curved providing seclusion from Alcoa Highway. That is all gone now with the new Dresser Road becoming the frontage road access to Martha Washington Heights which has open us up visually to new road work and bridges. Adding a commercial area at this entrance would further detract from the quite, woodsy feel of this subdivision of old homes. Do not redefine this community by rezoning this property.
Walter
37920
12-A-21-SP
Walter (37920), December 5, 2021 at 7:21 PM
Multiple empty business locations fill this sector. The need for additional mixed use is not needed and would be detrimental to the entrance of the homes in Martha Washington Heights.
WANDA
37920
11-B-21-SP
WANDA (37920), November 18, 2021 at 2:53 PM
Regarding the proposed development on Old Sevierville Pike and Dry Hollow, I am totally opposed to this development, First and foremost, the development will create a severe road hazard on Sevierville Pike. The road is a narrow, 2-lane road with curves and blind spots. People who live in the area know the existing hazards of the road and for the most part, drive accordingly. Adding 500-1200 more vehicles on this road will be a nightmare!. Where in the mind of Knox County government is concern for the safety of this community? And aside from the traffic and increased road hazard, does anyone not care that a community which had been here for over 100 years is facing complete demolition of life as we know it? AND, does anyone not care that the wildlife in this special place is in dire jeopardy of being completely destroyed as their habitat will be wiped out? Think about your neighborhood and if you would want such a development to destroy such a beautiful history. Greed may win the battle but it will not win the war!
William
37920
12-G-21-RZ
William (37920), December 8, 2021 at 2:13 PM
It would seem the request for rezoning would diminish greatly the peace and tranquility of the. Martha Washington heights homeowners. It also would seem totally unnecessary with all the properties already unoccupied down the street in a state of wasting away.Please do not undermine the integrity of this beautiful old and active community.