Historic Zoning Commission

Fairmont-Emoriland NC: Level II

10-E-24-HZ  

Staff Recommendation

The Commission should discuss the massing of the garage addition and the proposed front/east side addition. Pending input or additional conditions from the Commission, additional conditions of approval should include: 1) front/east addition to be revised in placement to meet the design guidelines; 2) additional landscape planting to be included in final side plan along east side property line to serve as screening for new garage and parking pad.


Applicant Request
New additions.

Front/east addition: new addition to east elevation along the façade, to measure 24'-6" wide by 12'-8" deep and be recessed 1'-5.5" from the front façade of the house. The front addition will feature a side-gable roof with an 8/12 pitch, an exterior of brick veneer, and two bays of 9/9 double-hung windows with "style, size, trim, and sill to match the existing," along with shutters to match the existing. Addition will feature brick quoins and a brick solider header course above the windows.

Covered porch addition: on the east elevation, located behind the proposed new front addition, a covered porch with a 2/12-pitch, shed roof will extend 22'-9.5" towards the rear of the house.

Garage addition: new three-car garage addition to the rear right corner (east elevation) of the house. The garage addition will measure 25' wide by 36'-1" deep and feature a 6/12 pitch hipped roof, an exterior of brick cladding, and three garage bays facing the east side elevation.

Rear addition: new addition to rear (south elevation) of house. The rear addition measures approximately 32'-2" wide (the full width of the existing house) by 17'-1.5" deep, and features a 6/12 pitch hipped roof and an exterior of brick cladding.

New driveway: new 12' wide driveway extending from Emoriland Boulevard, leading to an approximately 32' wide parking pad area outside the three-car garage.

Staff Comments
Colonial Revival, c.1927
    One story frame with brick veneer wall covering, corner quoins. Exterior end brick chimney. Side gable roof with asphalt shingle covering. One story gabled front portico with arched ceiling, replacement columns. Six over six double hung windows. Exterior end brick chimney. Rectangular plan.

1. 1916 Emoriland Boulevard is a contributing resource to the Fairmont Park NC Overlay. The house is a Colonial Revival-style Minimal Traditional house. Minimal Traditional houses are typically modest one-story forms with narrow facades and minimal architectural detail.

2. The proposed additions are significantly large in footprint, approximately doubling the overall square footage of the house.

3. Guidelines recommend that additions are placed on the side or rear of buildings, discouraging additions to the front that obscure original architectural designs. The proposed rear addition and garage additions meet the guidelines for placement. The front/east addition is set back from the façade by only 1'-5.5" and almost doubles the existing façade width. Guidelines note that "if additions are made to the existing building, they should be located at least 5' behind the front façade of the existing building." The front addition is not sufficiently differentiated from the original façade of the house and should be revised in placement.

4. The additions use materials and design elements compatible with the primary structure, including brick cladding, quoin detailing, brick soldier header courses above windows, and windows with sills and shutters to reflect the existing.

5. Guidelines recommend that doors of attached garages do not face Emoriland Boulevard, and they should be located at least 15' behind the front façade; the design does meet these guidelines. The garage will be large in scale and visible from the street due to the adjacent vacant property. Three-car garages are typically not in character with the neighborhood context. SOI Standards note that new additions "shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment." The Commission should discus the overall massing of the proposed garage.

6. Guidelines recommend that driveways be "as narrow as possible," 9'-12' wide, and encourage separate tire strips. The driveways are 12', comparable to the minimum required width of 10'. The parking pad outside of the three-car garage is relatively large. Additional landscaping and screening may serve to obscure the large garage and parking pad.
Applicant

Vince Marshall, Marshall Design & Construction Corp.


Planning Staff
Lindsay Crockett
Phone: 865-215-3795
Email: lindsay.crockett@knoxplanning.org
Location Knoxville
1916 Emoriland Blvd. 37917

Owner
Todd and Anita Davis

Case History