Download as PDF

Design Review Board

Oakwood/Lincoln Park Infill Housing Overlay District

8-A-20-IH

Location
715 Atlantic Ave. 37917
Owner
Gary Gary Koontz
Applicant Request
Changes to porches visible from the primary street
Staff recommends approval of the project due to the following findings:

1. The project restores a front porch which is more proportional to original houses on the block (p.9).
2. The new porch design involves replacing non-historic metal columns with wood posts, which are more in keeping with historic porch materials (p.9).
Staff Comments
This project involves the after-the-fact review of porch modifications.

Proposed Project
1. The house is a late Folk Victorian or early Craftsman-style house which has received significant modifications in the mid-twentieth century, including non-historic stone veneer siding, an enclosed front porch, and a midcentury picture window on the façade. The house no longer retains a distinguishable historic architectural style. The surrounding blocks feature Craftsman-style houses, Ranch houses, and infill construction.
2. The previous porch was a stoop, covered with a shed-roof metal awning, characteristic of mid-twentieth-century porch design.
3. The proposed scope of work includes replacing the flat-roof enclosed section with a front-gable roof which extends towards the street to provide a front-gable roof porch. The new roof has a 6/12 slope and incorporates eave overhangs on the side elevations.
4. The roof modifications do not expand the footprint of the front porch.
5. The applicant proposes to complete the project with 6" x 6" square wood posts and an open gable with diagonal cross bracing (or a "wagon wheel" design). The Committee has both approved open gable porch roofs and encouraged the use of siding on porch gables to better resemble historic porch designs.
Applicant

Gary Gary Koontz

Planning Staff
Michelle Portier
Phone: 865-215-3821
Email: michelle.portier@knoxplanning.org
Submit CommentsView Comments

Case History